Book Smarts

Which seals are worth their weight in gold—and which deserve only an honorable mention?

By Rebecca Ffrench

book awards

Once upon a time, there were mom-and-pop bookstores where clerks had trustworthy opinions and carefully edited selections of books for children (and adults). Maybe the occasional Caldecott or Newbery winner was propped on a stand for a little extra recognition. Nowadays, a quick trip to pick out a new book for your own kid or someone else's turns into an hour of wading through the retail circus: cardbord kiosks that feature cartoon-characters-cum-books, musical accompaniments to the classics, and titles with a dozen or so awards you've never heard of. Once a signal of excellence adorning only the very best titles—such as Where the Wild Things Are (the 1964 Caldecott winner) and A Wrinkle in Time (the 1963 Newbery winner)—the ubiquitous seals have become difficult to decipher, and to trust. On the following pages, Cookie has winnowed the list of children's book awards down to the most prominent—the ones you'll spot in stores and on library shelves—and given you the details behind those shiny decorations of honor.



Next Page: A guide to reading between the lines when shopping for kids' books

Read Image Credits

Cookie Magazine

subscribe to cookie

and get a FREE Recipe Booklet!

That's 12 issues for $12 plus $3 shipping and handling
*Plus applicable sales tax
Non-USA - Click Here
First Name
Last Name
Address 1
Address 2
City
 
Zip
E-mail

Cookie

Weekly

movie picks

Family Films

Grab the popcorn and enjoy these 25 timeless classics

Celebrity Profiles

Tips and trends from your favorite stars

Straight to DVD

Our reviews editor wades through his Netflix queue to help you prioritize yours
Show Cookie your favorite summer memory!
Subscribe to Cookie!

pretty easy

Cookie Polls

How often do you and your partner have date nights?
Tell Us What You Think