when parents attack, part 2
Warning: this post is neither funny nor heartwarming. Sorry.
We moms, we can't win. Either we're disciplining our kids too much, or not enough.
I considered not posting this anecdote. I didn't think I'd need to revisit this territory quite so soon. The incident I'm about to tell you actually happened a few months ago, but I decided to wait a while before writing about it. I thought by waiting I'd have the distance to add a touch of humor to the story. But somehow I still don't find anything funny about it. It's a very crabby story, in fact, about two crabby mommies and one crabby tot.
The scene: Busy Crabcity street, Sunday morning. Crabtot (she was still a tot then...not the almost-4-yr-old she is now) was having an "off" day after a busy weekend. We go into a store, whereupon Crabtot seizes a pair of sunglasses and tries to bend back the arms. I reprimand her, and she screams so loudly that the shop lady literally holds her hands to her ears and I don't blame her for doing so. It was excruciating. So I pick up Crabtot, tuck her under my arm—body flailing—and walk out. Crabtot attempts to bite me on the way out (a threat she used to make on occasion). And I bite her back.
Okay, so that last line was a joke (albeit a feeble one).
What really happened: I took my child outside, sat her down on a bench, and said the following: "Crabtot, what you did in there was inappropriate and disrespectful and it hurt Mommy on the inside and on the outside."
Okay, so that was another attempt at a lame joke. I didn't speak like that. If I had, I wouldn't be writing this piece. Nay, instead of speaking in even measured positive-parent-y tones, the Crabmommy sat Crabtot down, cupped her chin in my hand (forcing her to look me in the eye), and gave her what-for: "I've had enough of this behavior! How dare you scream like that and try to bite me!" That sort of thing. Yes, it was my outside voice. But we were, after all, outside.
Crabtot blubbed a ton and her eyes get extra-blue and extra-huge when she cries, so I realize she must have looked like an adorable—if miserable—cherub and I an evil glowering hag; still, in my book it doesn't excuse the following: I feel a tap on my shoulder and turn to find a woman three inches from my face. She has a newborn swaddled to her chest in a Mayan wrap and a look of flaming outrage on her mug. "What do you think you're doing?" she hisses.
Thus begins a mom-battle of words, between me and a stranger. She accuses me of being abusive and threatens to call the police. I tell her to go ahead. She calls me a maniac. I call her a maniac for calling me a maniac in front of my child. It's ugly. In the background her husband stands looking hapless and unsure. Eventually Righteous Mom stalks off and I am left shaking with indignation and embarrassment.
To rewind, was I screaming at Crabtot, loudly enough to validate the intervention of strangers? I was not. But did I sound like I was mad? Heck, yeah. Am I proud of it? Not really. Normally I would have escorted my kid off to our car and had the freakout privately, but disciplining off the public stage isn't always possible. What I don't get is how another mother could butt into such a situation and accuse me of something flagrant, illegal, and awful—child abuse!—when I wasn't even spanking my child (and last I checked that's not actually illegal in our state...yet).
Here's the way I see it: we all have our trying times as parents. We all also differ from each other as parents, just as our children differ from one another. My child is delightfully spunky and tenacious. And sometimes the spunkiness and tenacity—it's not delightful. And maybe the apple doesn't fall far from the tree, but why do I need to convince a stranger of my right to be who I am and be the mother I choose to be? This idea that all parents must be the same, handle their children in the same way, and respond in a uniform fashion to any and all challenging situations is bogus to me. It's stepfordmommy fascism.
Believe me, ye softmommies, there are plenty of things Crabmommy would love to say to you when I hear you pussy-footing around your badly behaved children. But I hold my tongue in person and blog about it in private, and I ask that, when you next come across a stranger-mom who sounds stern or says "no" or does something else you deem scary and freaky, you hold off on the harsh words until you get home to your blog. Then, by all means, go nuts.
The irony of that day? Crabtot's protector terrified her. On the positive side, I think that chick nipped the biting thing in the bud. Something about having a stranger tell Mommy the police might take her away...I think it sealed Crabtot's jaws once and for all. And that isn't really very funny, is it?
Imperfect Mommies, I have a message for you: the Perfect Mother Police are out there. And they are watching, always, and ready to pounce. Be afraid. Be very afraid.
So what about you? Have you ever told someone off in public? Or have you been the recipient of a dressing down by a stranger? Do I scarrrrrrre you with my CRAZY CRABMOMMY TEMPER? Give me your two cents'!








